Soviet era instructions for putting in foot-cloths (Photo: WikiCommons)
***
Alan: Conservative Russians oppose tjhe "innovation" of socks whereas liberal Russians support socks, demonstrating (to my satisfaction) that conservatives cling to tradition simply because it's traditional. Traditions are the "behavioral equivalent" of comfort foods, and very often comfort foods are not "good for you."
George McGovern argues that conservatives "hold politics hostage to the past" whereas liberals quickly abandon "the counterproductive past" in order to improve the future. McGovern's essay, "The Case For Liberalism: Defense Of The Future Against The Past," is located at http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2012/01/george-mcgovern-case-for-liberalism.html
Imagine. Russia is conducting a national political debate over foot cloths!
American conservatives will read the following article and, motivated by "conservative solidarity," many will reflexively defend foot cloths. Yet not one American believes foot cloths are actually superior to socks. In this instance, at least, not one will put his "portyanki" feet where his mouth is.
![]()
![]()
***
Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu, called Monday for Russian soldiers to start using socks.
Socks have been standard issue in the Russian army since 2007, but it appears most Russian units prefer that their soldiers use traditional foot-cloths, known as ‘portyanki.’
Some in Russia see the foot-cloths as shamefully old-fashioned.
“This is 2013,” said Shoigu. “We are still talking about foot cloths.”
But the cloths are an ancient tradition, providing continuity to the pre-Soviet army of the old Russian empire.
Many veterans say they prefer them to socks, being more comfortable with tall boots.
Portyanki also dry faster than socks when wet, according to their aficionados.
‘Portyanki’ are a potent cultural icon to many Russians. Here a soldier dries his foot-cloths, in 1962 picture by Y.G.Gorelov. (Photo: Wiki Commons)
But many conscripts dislike them.
“If you don’t tie them properly they can bunch up and give you horrible blisters,” says Svetlana Savranskaya.
Savranskaya is director of Russian programs at the National Security Archive at George Washington University.
“I was surprised how the portyanki issue has become almost a litmus test for your political opinions in Russia,” she adds.
“Most of the liberal sites on the Russian internet are strongly in favor of the decision, saying it’s uncivilized,” says Savranskaya, “At the same time, the more conservative sites, more Russian patriot sites, all spoke in favor of portyanki, saying they’re part of Russian military traditions.”