The segment started with a video of Rush Limbaugh accusing the Pope of being a Marxist. Jonathan Karl asked Cokie Roberts about the Pope’s impact. She stated that the Pope has shaken up the church. He is bringing the church back to being more like Jesus. She is puzzled that some have reacted the way they have. “They clearly have not spent much time reading the New Testament,” she said.
Alan: Here is a good "test" for Catholics who are not inclined to read The Four Gospels cover to cover. Using the following red-lined text, read every word Jesus spoke in Matthew, Mark, Luke and John http://www.ccel.org/bible/phillips/JBPRed.htm As you read, make a hash-mark every time you disagree with something he says. Examples: "Love your enemy.""Turn the other cheek.""Pray for those who persecute." "Give to anyone who asks." “No one can serve two masters. Either you will hate the one and love the other, or you will be devoted to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve both God and money." I would venture that most conservative Catholics will substantially (if not categorically) disagree with most of Jesus' moral enjoinders.
Robert Reich chimed in saying that the Pope had the temerity to take on supply side economics. Reich referred to supply side causing inequality as a kind of ‘savagery’.
Jonathan Karl then asked Newt Gingrich if Republicans should be talking about inequality. Gingrich said they should. He said the Republican Party needed to address some of the indifference his party has towards the very poor. Gingrich then tried to segue into claiming the war on poverty was a failure. It was clear Cokie Roberts was attempting to get in to refute Newt Gingrich but was ignored.
Robert Reich slams Newt Gingrich for GOP complicity in income inequality.
Instead Robert Reich chimed in and reminded Gingrich that in fact the war on poverty was successful. Reich then implied that it was policies of the last thirty years (Reaganomics) that stunted progress.
Jonathan Karl as most in the ‘Liberal Media‘ do, attempted to bolster the Republican (Newt Gingrich) by asking why in the five years of the Obama administration, inequality has gotten worse. Robert Reich went for the jugular. He said it perhaps had to do with the intransigence of Newt Gingrich’s Party, the Republican Party. “Every time there was a jobs bill. Every time there was an effort to expand low income housing, every time there was an effort to provide better opportunity for young people,” he said.
Newt Gingrich tries to refute Robert Reich with false and empty rhetoric.
Newt Gingrich interrupted and called Robert Reich’s truthful statements baloney. Gingrich then lied and said every major city which is a center of poverty is run by Democrats. The reality is two out of the top five are run by Republicans. Newt Gingrich then attempted to imply that it was Democratic policies in those cities that caused poverty. Cokie Roberts was attempting to get in seemingly to say that it wasn’t local policies that cause poverty.
Newt Gingrich was attempting to do what those on the Right do all the time. Mix two unrelated facts to come out with an outcome. The poverty in major cities is pronounced because of the concentration of people. Rural areas and areas in Appalachia and throughout the country experience poverty as well. They are just not in urban centers with a lot of media coverage.
The discussion between Robert Reich and Newt Gingrich show the difference between empty rhetoric with mindless talking points and fact base information. More Liberals should take heed and hit Republican irresponsibility, disdain for the poor, and disdain for the working middle class hard whenever they spill their evil deeds. They must reach not only to the mind but to the hearts by articulating policy in milk, bread, butter, employment, and family values.
I interviewed former Clinton Labor Secretary Professor Robert Reich a few weeks ago about his new film “Inequality for All.” Check out the interview here. http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/12/16/1263091/-Robert-Reich-shocks-Newt-Gingrich-with-his-aggressive-pushback?detail=email